The Elusive Pursuit of Happiness: Why We’re Terrible at Predicting What Makes Us Happy

Happy Girl holding balloon | Know What Makes Us Happy with Happiness 2.0


The pursuit of happiness has been a timeless quest for humanity, with individuals continuously seeking the secret to eternal bliss. Yet, despite our relentless pursuit, we often find ourselves baffled and frustrated by our inability to accurately predict what will genuinely make us happy. In his book “Stumbling on Happiness,” psychologist Daniel Gilbert delves into the intricacies of human cognition, revealing why we consistently miss the mark in forecasting our happiness. This blog post explores the fascinating insights from Gilbert’s work and sheds light on the cognitive biases that hinder our ability to predict what truly brings us joy.

The Inherent Flaws of Imagination

One of the primary reasons we fail to forecast our happiness accurately lies in the inherent flaws of human imagination. Gilbert points out that when we try to envision future scenarios and their impact on our happiness, our minds tend to operate in a “fill-in-the-blanks” manner. Our imaginations are constrained by our current experiences, and we often rely on past memories as a reference point for projecting future emotions.

For example, imagine being given a choice between going on a luxurious vacation to a tropical island or spending time with close friends and family during a holiday season. While you might imagine basking in the sun and enjoying the island getaway, Gilbert argues that you are likely to underestimate the joy of the latter, as you fail to fully grasp the warmth and emotional connections shared with loved ones during such occasions.

Gilbert suggests that our inability to fully grasp the emotional nuances of a future event or circumstance leads us to make flawed predictions. This can manifest in both overestimating the intensity of positive emotions and underestimating our resilience to cope with adversity. As a result, we often find ourselves dissatisfied with the outcomes, despite initially believing they would bring boundless happiness.

Excerpt from “Stumbling on Happiness”:
“Our imagination isn’t a window on the future; it’s a mirror reflecting our past experiences.”

Impact Bias: Overestimating the Effects of Life Events

The impact bias is a cognitive tendency that leads us to overestimate the emotional impact of significant life events, be they positive or negative. Whether it’s landing a dream job, winning the lottery, or experiencing heartbreak, we tend to believe that these events will have a much greater and enduring effect on our happiness than they actually do.

Gilbert illustrates this point with various real-life examples. For instance, people often expect a promotion to bring unparalleled happiness, only to find that the initial euphoria fades with time, and they adapt to the new circumstances. Similarly, the pain of heartbreak, though excruciating at first, eventually subsides as we gradually recover and find new sources of joy.

Understanding the impact bias can liberate us from the false belief that achieving certain milestones will result in perpetual bliss. Instead, it encourages us to focus on the present moment, savoring the happiness that these events bring without overly relying on them for long-term contentment.

Excerpt from “Stumbling on Happiness”:
“The intensity and duration of our emotional responses are largely determined by the peculiarities of our brain’s software, rather than by the objective circumstances of our lives.”

The Power of Adaptation

Another significant obstacle in predicting our happiness is the psychological phenomenon known as “hedonic adaptation.” It refers to our tendency to return to a baseline level of happiness after experiencing both positive and negative life events. No matter how euphoric or distressing an event may be, we eventually acclimate to the new circumstances, and the impact on our happiness diminishes over time.

Consider the example of purchasing a new car. The initial excitement and thrill of owning a shiny, new vehicle might lead to a surge of happiness. However, over time, this feeling wanes as the car becomes a familiar part of our daily routine. This adaptability is a double-edged sword, as it enables us to bounce back from adversity, but it also means that we get used to positive changes in our lives, leading us to seek more in an endless pursuit of happiness.

Understanding hedonic adaptation allows us to appreciate the fleeting nature of emotional highs and lows. It reminds us that genuine and lasting happiness often comes from appreciating the ordinary moments, finding joy in the simple pleasures, and cultivating gratitude for what we have.

Excerpt from “Stumbling on Happiness”:
“If we wish to know how happy a person will be in the future, all we have to know is how happy they are today.”

Social Comparison and the Hedonic Treadmill

Social comparison is a pervasive aspect of human behavior, where we assess our happiness and success relative to others. Unfortunately, this habit often leads us to chase unfulfilling goals, as we measure our own happiness against those who appear to have more or seem happier.

In the age of social media, the urge to compare ourselves to others has become more potent than ever. Scrolling through carefully curated posts and profiles can create feelings of inadequacy and discontent, prompting us to believe that we are missing out on the key to happiness possessed by others.
This phenomenon, combined with the hedonic treadmill effect, creates a vicious cycle where we continuously strive for more, never truly reaching a lasting state of happiness. As we achieve our aspirations and improve our circumstances, we quickly adapt to these changes, and our happiness set-point rises accordingly, compelling us to seek new sources of pleasure and accomplishment.

To break free from the shackles of social comparison and the hedonic treadmill, we must shift our focus inward, introspecting on our values and personal aspirations. Embracing gratitude for our unique journey and learning to derive satisfaction from our own growth and progress can lead us toward genuine and sustainable happiness.

Excerpt from “Stumbling on Happiness”:
“We are happy when we have family, we are happy when we have friends and almost all the other things we think make us happy are actually just ways of getting more family and friends.”


The enigma of predicting our happiness continues to baffle us, but understanding the underlying cognitive biases and psychological mechanisms can help us navigate this complex journey. Daniel Gilbert’s “Stumbling on Happiness” provides invaluable insights into why we are inherently bad at forecasting our well-being. From the limitations of imagination to the power of adaptation and social comparison, these factors influence our perceptions of happiness.

Instead of solely relying on predictions, perhaps the key lies in embracing the present moment and finding joy in the journey itself. By appreciating the small pleasures and fostering genuine connections with others, we can gradually build a more content and meaningful life. In acknowledging the flaws in our ability to predict happiness, we open the door to a more profound understanding of ourselves and a greater appreciation for the beauty of life’s unpredictable twists and turns.

Check out the podcast episode…

Check out the Happiness 2.0 Podcast

Subscribe to the Happiness 2.0 Newsletter

Get easy to implement happiness tools in your inbox weekly.
Share the happiness

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *